Journal · On Musicianship
The University and the Forest
On one side, the people of the forest, who play only from the heart. On the other, the scientists, who trust only the mind. The secret is that you were never meant to choose.
There is a university, and there is a forest. Every musician is pushed to live in one of them — and that pushing is the whole mistake.
On one side stand the people of the forest. Forget about your brain and play from your heart, they say. Feel the music. Full spirit. Free from the intellect. The forest people do not trouble themselves with the knowledge of music. They don’t bother learning, or acquiring skills. They do not study the theories of rhythm and harmony. Music is spirit, they say — it is connected to intuition, and your brain is the one thing standing in the way.
On the other side stand the scientists. Forget about spirit and all that nonsense. Music is math. Know the rules, know the harmony, know your music theory — and you will be a good musician. Who cares whether you have spirit? If you cannot hold time, your spirit is worthless. And what is spirit, anyway?
Here is the thing: they are both right — and they are both wrong.
Spirit by itself, when it is not rooted in knowledge, is hollow. Yes, you may have moments of epiphany — moments of deep connectedness through the music. But when they leave, and the music stops, you will not be able to repeat what happened, or share it, or even understand it. You are left forever at the mercy of the spirit’s next visit.
On all the other days, you find that the forest people are actually very limited in their vocabulary. Intuition is only a kinder word for the things they already know — a name for the familiar. They find it painfully hard to evolve, because they do not know where to go, or what they are even looking for. They play with spirit, they play with heart — but musically they are stuck on repeat. The same handful of grooves return, year after year, a little more polished but never truly new. There is a ceiling in the forest, and from the inside it is almost impossible to see. If you are trying to expand your own voice, spirit, most of the time, is simply not enough.
The scientists, on the other hand, hold the power of the intellect — and it is a very powerful thing. They can produce infinite amounts of new phrases. They set off on long intellectual quests into the valleys and mountains of the brain, and return with music that nobody moves to. Nobody is crying. Not a single hair in the room is standing on end. It is impressive. It is often flawless. And it is dead on arrival.
Why? Because they forgot that beauty cannot be broken down into numbers. Because knowledge, on its own, is not enough. There is a whole other layer to music — one that cannot be spoken about, cannot be analysed, cannot be calculated.
There is a layer of music that cannot be spoken, cannot be analysed, cannot be counted. The only way to reach it is through the heart.
Here is the good news: you do not actually have to choose. You can — and you should — hold both hats at once, and wear the right one at the right moment.
Visit the university. Put the scientist’s hat on when you want to explore new territory, to go searching for something you have never played before. Then take what you found and carry it back to the forest. Play it around the fire of your heart — and see whether anyone begins to dance.
This is what all that knowledge is really for. Not to replace the heart, but to hand it a map — to point past the clearing you already know, and give you a way to walk out of it. The forest tells you whether a place is worth reaching; the university helps you find the way there.
I keep one uncompromising rule, and it gives the forest the final word: if a phrase does not pass the test of the forest, I throw it away — however clever it looked back at the university.
And it runs the other way, too. Sometimes the forest hands you a phrase, or a groove, that makes no sense scientifically at all. If it passes the test of the heart, I cherish it — and I stop trying to understand it.
Without knowledge, spirit is a hollow wind. Without spirit, knowledge is a barren tree. So carry both hats — and let the forest have the last word.
Explore the Classes →Curious where you’d begin? Start the free Groove Builder Challenge →
Live online lessons across four instruments. Keep reading: Poetry Over Speed · The Teacher’s Responsibility · The Dream That Was Never Mine