Journal · On Expression
The Embrace
How to make your playing personal.
We can all feel the difference between a real embrace and a polite one. A drum can feel it too — and so can everyone listening.
Think about a hug. We can all feel, instantly, the difference between someone who is genuinely holding us and someone who is keeping their distance while their arms go through the motions. And we feel it from the inside too — we know, in ourselves, when we have truly embraced someone and when we have stayed somewhere behind our own arms. The body is almost identical in both cases. The difference is entirely on the inside. And it is unmistakable.
Playing is exactly the same.
A listener can feel whether you have actually given yourself to the music or whether you are holding it at arm’s length — performing it correctly, from a safe distance. They may not have words for it. But they feel it, the same way they feel a hug that doesn’t quite arrive. And here is the uncomfortable part: you can play every phrase perfectly — clean technique, right notes, good time — and still leave a room cold, because you never made the inner movement toward what you were playing. You stayed distant.
That inner movement is the whole thing. To play personally is to lean in — to close the distance between yourself and the music instead of standing outside it and operating it. It is a decision you make on the inside, beneath the notes, and it has nothing to do with how your hands look and everything to do with where you are while they move.
This is the mistake I see most often in capable players, and it is a subtle one. They believe that if they get the phrases right, the feeling will follow — so they polish the phrases. But the phrases are the arms of the hug. They are not the hug. You can have flawless arms and still hold someone at a distance. The phrases are the physical gesture; the closeness is something else entirely, and it has to come from you, deliberately, every time you play. Do not confuse the two.
A perfect phrase played from far away is still played from far away. Everyone can hear it.
So how do you make your playing personal? You stop waiting for the music to move you, and you move toward it. Before the phrase, underneath it, you make the inner turn — the same turn you make when you decide to really hold someone rather than just put your arms around them. It is quiet. No one watching would see it. But it changes everything that comes out of the drum.
I am not talking about playing louder, or adding more, or performing your emotion on your face. None of that is closeness — often it is the opposite, a louder way of staying distant. The inner movement is not a performance. It is private. It is you, genuinely arriving at the music, and then letting the drum carry that arrival to whoever is listening.
A drum is a strange and honest instrument. It cannot lie about where you are. If you are distant, it sounds distant — competent, maybe even impressive, but distant. And if you make that inner movement, if you truly embrace what you are playing, the drum carries that closeness across the room and sets it down in another person’s chest. That is the whole art. Not the phrases. The embrace inside them.
Get the arms right, yes. And then — close the distance.
Explore the Classes →Live online lessons across four instruments — or read about the Afterman Method · Next in the Journal: Poetry Over Speed.